Trump warns of 'dangerous low' in Russia relations

Trump warns of 'dangerous low' in Russia relations


By Stephen Collinson, CNN

Updated 1246 GMT (2046 HKT) August 3, 2017

trump putin us russia trade

Now Playing Trump signs Russia...
US President Barack Obama (R) meets his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin (L) in Los Cabos, Mexico, on June 18, 2012, during the G20 leaders Summit. Obama met today Putin at a G20 summit to discuss differences over what to do about the bloody conflict in Syria. AFP PHOTO/ RIA-NOVOSTI POOL / ALEXEI NIKOLSKY (Photo credit should read ALEXEI NIKOLSKY/AFP/GettyImages)
Is this the new Cold War?
Russian spy released from prison and deported
US President Barack Obama (R) listens to Russian President Vladimir Putin after their bilateral meeting in Los Cabos, Mexico on June 18, 2012 on the sidelines of the G20 summit. Obama and President Vladimir Putin met Monday, for the first time since the Russian leader's return to the presidency, for talks overshadowed by a row over Syria. The closely watched meeting opened half-an-hour late on the sidelines of the G20 summit of developed and developing nations, as the US leader sought to preserve his "reset" of ties with Moscow despite building disagreements. AFP PHOTO/Jewel Samad (Photo credit should read JEWEL SAMAD/AFP/Getty Images)
Obama orders Russian hacking probe
McCain: People are 'giving up on the West'
Russian President Vladimir Putin (R) greets his Syrian counterpart Bashar al-Assad upon his arrival for a meeting at the Kremlin in Moscow on October 20, 2015. Assad, on his first foreign visit since Syria's war broke out, told his main backer and counterpart Putin in Moscow that Russia's campaign in Syria has helped contain "terrorism". / AFP / RIA NOVOSTI / ALEXEY DRUZHININ (Photo credit should read ALEXEY DRUZHININ/AFP/Getty Images)
What are Russia's objectives in Syria?
Senators promise Russian sanctions
Is this the most powerful man in the world?
The Cold War: Then and now
trump putin us russia trade
Now Playing
Trump signs Russia sanctions bill
US President Donald Trump holds a joint press conference with his Polish counterpart at the Royal Castle in Warsaw, Poland, July 6, 2017. / AFP PHOTO / SAUL LOEB (Photo credit should read SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images)
WH: Trump to sign Russia sanctions bill
Russian President Vladimir Putin speak to the media after touring the Hannover Messe 2013 industrial trade fair on April 8, 2013 in Hanover, Germany. Merkel and Putin toured the fair, which is the world's largest industry trade fair and has partnered this year with Russia.
Russia retaliates against US after sanctions
BERLIN, GERMANY - OCTOBER 19: Russian President Vladimir Putin attends a meeting to discuss the Ukrainian peace process at the German federal Chancellery on October 19, 2016 in Berlin, Germany. The leaders of Russia, Ukraine, France and Germany, known as the Normandy Four, met in Berlin to discuss implementation of the peace plan known as the Minsk Protocol, a roadmap for resolving the conflict in Ukraine after Russian forces invaded in 2014 and annexed the peninsula of Crimea. The United States has threatened renewed sanctions on Russia if the country did not either implement the plan in the coming months or arrive at a plan on how to do so. (Photo by Adam Berry/Getty Images)
Senate sends Russia sanctions bill to Trump
Vladimir Putin on Trump US politics _00003422.jpg
Putin: Claims of election interference are 'anti-Russia hysteria'
russia sanctions phil black lok_00011312.jpg
Russian leaders lash out at US sanctions
An image published by the Makeyev Rocket Design Bureau of the RS-28 Sarmat rocket, or 'Satan 2.'
First photos of Russia's 'Satan 2' missile released
US President Barack Obama (R) meets his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin (L) in Los Cabos, Mexico, on June 18, 2012, during the G20 leaders Summit. Obama met today Putin at a G20 summit to discuss differences over what to do about the bloody conflict in Syria. AFP PHOTO/ RIA-NOVOSTI POOL / ALEXEI NIKOLSKY (Photo credit should read ALEXEI NIKOLSKY/AFP/GettyImages)
Is this the new Cold War?
Russian spy released from prison and deported
US President Barack Obama (R) listens to Russian President Vladimir Putin after their bilateral meeting in Los Cabos, Mexico on June 18, 2012 on the sidelines of the G20 summit. Obama and President Vladimir Putin met Monday, for the first time since the Russian leader's return to the presidency, for talks overshadowed by a row over Syria. The closely watched meeting opened half-an-hour late on the sidelines of the G20 summit of developed and developing nations, as the US leader sought to preserve his "reset" of ties with Moscow despite building disagreements. AFP PHOTO/Jewel Samad (Photo credit should read JEWEL SAMAD/AFP/Getty Images)
Obama orders Russian hacking probe
McCain: People are 'giving up on the West'
Russian President Vladimir Putin (R) greets his Syrian counterpart Bashar al-Assad upon his arrival for a meeting at the Kremlin in Moscow on October 20, 2015. Assad, on his first foreign visit since Syria's war broke out, told his main backer and counterpart Putin in Moscow that Russia's campaign in Syria has helped contain "terrorism". / AFP / RIA NOVOSTI / ALEXEY DRUZHININ (Photo credit should read ALEXEY DRUZHININ/AFP/Getty Images)
What are Russia's objectives in Syria?
Senators promise Russian sanctions
Is this the most powerful man in the world?
The Cold War: Then and now
trump putin us russia trade
Trump signs Russia sanctions bill
US President Donald Trump holds a joint press conference with his Polish counterpart at the Royal Castle in Warsaw, Poland, July 6, 2017. / AFP PHOTO / SAUL LOEB (Photo credit should read SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images)
WH: Trump to sign Russia sanctions bill
Russian President Vladimir Putin speak to the media after touring the Hannover Messe 2013 industrial trade fair on April 8, 2013 in Hanover, Germany. Merkel and Putin toured the fair, which is the world's largest industry trade fair and has partnered this year with Russia.
Russia retaliates against US after sanctions
BERLIN, GERMANY - OCTOBER 19: Russian President Vladimir Putin attends a meeting to discuss the Ukrainian peace process at the German federal Chancellery on October 19, 2016 in Berlin, Germany. The leaders of Russia, Ukraine, France and Germany, known as the Normandy Four, met in Berlin to discuss implementation of the peace plan known as the Minsk Protocol, a roadmap for resolving the conflict in Ukraine after Russian forces invaded in 2014 and annexed the peninsula of Crimea. The United States has threatened renewed sanctions on Russia if the country did not either implement the plan in the coming months or arrive at a plan on how to do so. (Photo by Adam Berry/Getty Images)
Senate sends Russia sanctions bill to Trump
Vladimir Putin on Trump US politics _00003422.jpg
Putin: Claims of election interference are 'anti-Russia hysteria'
russia sanctions phil black lok_00011312.jpg
Russian leaders lash out at US sanctions
An image published by the Makeyev Rocket Design Bureau of the RS-28 Sarmat rocket, or 'Satan 2.'
First photos of Russia's 'Satan 2' missile released
US President Barack Obama (R) meets his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin (L) in Los Cabos, Mexico, on June 18, 2012, during the G20 leaders Summit. Obama met today Putin at a G20 summit to discuss differences over what to do about the bloody conflict in Syria. AFP PHOTO/ RIA-NOVOSTI POOL / ALEXEI NIKOLSKY (Photo credit should read ALEXEI NIKOLSKY/AFP/GettyImages)
Is this the new Cold War?
Story highlights

Politics in both nations outpace the capacity of either to mitigate the danger
Sanctions bill reflected bipartisan skepticism over Trump's motivations toward Russia

Washington (CNN)The United States and Russia are plunging deeper into their worst crisis since the Cold War, with politics in both nations outpacing the capacity of either government to mitigate the danger.
President Donald Trump's grudging signature on new sanctions punishing Russia for alleged meddling in last year's US election sparked an explosive rhetorical response in Moscow on Wednesday.
Sponsor Content
International Money Transfers Made Easy
CNN has teamed up with foreign exchange experts, moneycorp, to provide you with CNN Money Transfers.
Content provided by CNN Money Transfers

Trump acknowledged the sharp worsening of the crucial relationship between the world's two top nuclear powers Thursday morning -- and blamed lawmakers for forcing his hand on sanctions.
"Our relationship with Russia is at an all-time & very dangerous low. You can thank Congress, the same people that can't even give us HCare!" he tweeted.
But the perilous situation is also being exacerbated by the lack of a clear White House approach toward Russia. A simultaneous policy of accommodation and confrontation toward Moscow combined with a tussle for influence between Congress and the President threaten to sow confusion that could increase the chances of a miscalculation between the two foes.
"I think it is very unclear exactly where the administration intends to go in our dealings with Russia or how it intends to put together a coherent strategy for dealing with Moscow," said George Beebe, a former director of Russia analysis for the CIA.
"I think there is actually a very real risk that we could get into an escalatory spiral that would be difficult for either country to control," said Beebe, now with the Center for the National Interest.
Trump's Russia statement proves he doesn't understand separation of powers
Trump's Russia statement proves he doesn't understand separation of powers
Moscow's protests on Wednesday after Trump signed the sanctions bill reflected fury at the new constraints on the Russian economy -- and perhaps also political pressures that left the government little option but to escalate the situation.
And for the first time, there was a note of personal contempt for Trump himself, which may reflect disappointment in Moscow that the President was unable to make good on his promise to improve relations with Russia.
"The Trump administration has shown its total weakness by handing over executive power to Congress in the most humiliating way. This changes the power balance in US political circles," said Russian Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev in a Facebook post. "The US establishment fully outwitted Trump; the President is not happy about the new sanctions, yet he could not but sign the bill."
The attack followed Russian President Vladimir Putin's announcement on Sunday that the US must cut its diplomatic staff in Russia by 755 people, in a delayed response to the seizure of Russian compounds and the expulsion of 35 diplomats by the Obama administration to punish the alleged election meddling.
The sanctions bill, passed with veto-proof majorities in Congress, reflected bipartisan skepticism over Trump's motivations toward Russia and fueled impressions the White House can't control its own foreign policy.
Trump and Putin are locked in a hellish standoff
Trump and Putin are locked in a hellish standoff
Trump released a signing statement and press release, arguing that the measure, which limits his power to ease the sanctions, posed constitutional questions. And the President refused to abandon his position that improving relations with Russia -- which most people in Washington regard as a serious threat to US interests -- was a laudable foreign policy goal.
"We hope there will be cooperation between our two countries on major global issues so that these sanctions will no longer be necessary," Trump wrote.
But top lawmakers gave little ground.
"The concerns expressed in the President's signing statement are hardly surprising, though misplaced," said Republican Sen. John McCain of Arizona, the chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee.
Maryland Sen. Ben Cardin, the top Democrat on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, said, "We make the laws, not the President of the United States."
Russia sanctions: What you need to know
Russia sanctions: What you need to know
Wednesday's events will fuel impressions in both Washington and Moscow that Trump's weakened political position is threatening his capacity to carry out his own core foreign policy goals.
They are also raising new questions about Trump's willingness to accept the limits on his own power inherent in the US system of government.
It's not unusual for a President to register frustration with congressional attempts to force his hand on national security issues -- both George W. Bush and Barack Obama used signing statements.
But discord between a president and Congress is more unusual when it comes to the questions of economic sanctions against a rival power.
"Given the statements out of the White House today, Trump detractors could view this as a bit chaotic and as further proof that the executive branch needs congressional oversight on foreign policy issues," said Lawrence Ward, a partner at Dorsey & Whitney, a firm specializing in US national security law.
Trump signs Russia sanctions bill
Trump signs Russia sanctions bill
"So, by extension, it is fairly easy to envision how other parts of the world could be wondering whether it is President Trump or Congress pulling the foreign policy strings," Ward said.
Still Ward noted that Trump did sign the sanctions and, in doing so, he presented a united front with Congress toward Moscow -- a point also made by Senate Foreign Relations Committee chairman Bob Corker.
"I'm satisfied with what's happened and have no concerns whatsoever," the Tennessee Republican said.
But the sense of uncertainty around a Russia policy for the United States is being compounded by conflicting messages from the administration.
While Trump was talking about future cooperation with Moscow, his vice president has been spelling out a far more hawkish and conventional Republican line toward Moscow during a trip in Eastern Europe this week.
"No threat looms larger in the Baltic states than the specter of aggression from your unpredictable neighbor to the east," Vice President Mike Pence said in Estonia on Monday.
US considers option of arming Ukraine
US considers option of arming Ukraine
His comments were far more robust than any made in Europe by Trump, who has been solicitous to Russia for his entire presidency. Yet on Wednesday, Pence also left open the door for engagement with Moscow, telling The Washington Post the President was taking a "we'll see" attitude toward Russia.
Lawmakers meanwhile reacted angrily Wednesday to reports that Secretary of State Rex Tillerson is not spending money at his disposal to counter Russian disinformation.
Another sign the administration wants to keep Russia on its side came at the G20 summit last month, when the President had a prolonged conversation with Putin at a leaders' dinner.
At earlier formal talks, the leaders agreed upon a ceasefire deal in southwest Syria. Then Trump ended covert US aid to Syrian rebels trying to topple Assad, seemingly playing into another Russian foreign policy goal.
Yet in April, Trump ordered military action against Russian-backed Syrian forces to punish the use of chemical weapons. And there have been multiple reports the Pentagon and State Department are pushing to send lethal aid to the Ukrainian government -- a move that would likely further inflame US-Russia relations.
Short of such a step, however, it is not certain that Moscow-Washington ties are headed for a renewal of the Cold War. Both presidents have sent subtle signals in recent days they want to contain the damage.
Funds to counter Russia, extremists gather dust at State Department
Funds to counter Russia, extremists gather dust at State Department
Putin ordered the cuts in US diplomatic staff before Trump signed the sanctions bill -- so it looked like he was responding to Congress and not Trump. The fact that Medvedev -- not Putin -- issued a tirade against the new sanctions may also be significant.
Trump meanwhile signed the bill behind closed doors, and is yet to respond to Putin's move on US diplomats -- a possible sign that he also wants to avoid a personal escalation with his Kremlin counterpart.
Yet an uncontrollable spike in tensions remains a real danger.
"The situation's been bad, but believe me, it can get worse," Tillerson told reporters on Tuesday, paraphrasing his warning to Putin and Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov during a meeting in Moscow in April.
"And it just did."